JRE 1643 · June 27, 2024
Jonathan Zimmerman
Who is Jonathan Zimmerman?
Jonathan Zimmerman is a professor of education and history at the University of Pennsylvania and author of "Free Speech and Why You Should Give a Damn".
Topics and Timestamps
- 01Jonathan Zimmerman discusses the importance of free speech and why protecting it matters for society
- 02The conversation explores how free speech principles apply to modern cancel culture and social media
- 03Zimmerman explains the historical context of free speech battles in American education
- 04Discussion covers the tension between protecting speech and preventing harm or offense
- 05The episode examines how universities handle controversial speakers and student activism
- 06Zimmerman argues for the value of hearing opposing viewpoints even when deeply disagreeable
- ▶Zimmerman introduces his book's thesis and why free speech matters beyond principle0:00:00
- ▶Discussion of how universities have handled controversial speakers and student activism0:15:30
- ▶Exploration of the difference between offensive speech and genuinely dangerous speech0:35:00
- ▶Zimmerman explains historical precedents for free speech battles in American education0:55:00
- ▶Joe and Zimmerman debate the practical limits of free speech and social responsibility1:20:00
The Show
Joe brings on Jonathan Zimmerman, a University of Pennsylvania professor and author of 'Free Speech and Why You Should Give a Damn,' to dig into one of the most contentious issues facing modern society: free speech and its limits. This isn't your typical libertarian 'free speech absolutist' conversation either. Zimmerman comes at this from a historical and educational perspective, grounding the discussion in real examples of how speech restrictions have played out in schools and universities over decades.
The core of their conversation centers on why free speech matters beyond just some abstract principle. Zimmerman makes the case that exposure to ideas you disagree with, even strongly, is essential for developing critical thinking and understanding how to argue effectively. The book's title itself is a direct challenge: why should you give a damn? Because your ability to convince others depends on it, and because silencing people rarely makes their ideas go away. It usually just drives them underground or radicalizes them further.
They explore the tension between free speech and the very real desire to protect people from harmful speech. It's not a simple binary. Zimmerman acknowledges that speech can cause genuine harm, but argues that the solution isn't necessarily censorship. Instead, he pushes back against the idea that universities and platforms should be in the business of protecting students from offensive or disagreeable ideas. That's supposed to be what education is for.
The conversation gets into how universities have handled controversial speakers, student protests, and the pressure institutions face to disinvite speakers or discipline professors. Zimmerman grounds this in historical perspective, showing how these battles aren't new. There's always been tension between who gets to speak and whose voices are heard. The difference now is the speed and scale of social media amplifying these conflicts.
What makes this conversation valuable is that Zimmerman isn't dismissing concerns about hate speech or genuinely dangerous rhetoric. He's arguing for a more nuanced approach: understand the distinction between speech you find offensive and speech that actually incites violence. Know the difference between criticism and censorship. And recognize that your ability to suppress views you hate also creates the tools that can be used against views you love.
Joe and Zimmerman dig into specific examples and hypotheticals throughout, with Joe pushing back on certain points and genuinely engaging with the argument rather than just nodding along. It's the kind of substantive conversation that actually explores an idea rather than just confirming what you already believe.
Best Quotes
“Free speech isn't just about protecting popular ideas, it's about protecting your right to convince people who disagree with you”
— Jonathan Zimmerman
From the JRE 1643 conversation with Jonathan Zimmerman.
“Universities should be places where you encounter ideas that make you uncomfortable, that's the whole point”
— Joe Rogan
From the JRE 1643 conversation with Jonathan Zimmerman.
“Silencing people doesn't make their ideas disappear, it just drives them underground”
— Jonathan Zimmerman
From the JRE 1643 conversation with Jonathan Zimmerman.
“There's a difference between criticism and censorship, and we're losing sight of that distinction”
— Joe Rogan
From the JRE 1643 conversation with Jonathan Zimmerman.
“If you give institutions the power to suppress speech you hate, you're creating the same tools that can be used against you”
— Jonathan Zimmerman
From the JRE 1643 conversation with Jonathan Zimmerman.
Mentioned in This Episode
Books, supplements, gear, and other cool things that came up in conversation — not the podcast ads.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.