JRE 1673 · June 27, 2024
Colin Wright
Who is Colin Wright?
Colin Wright is a biologist and Managing Editor of "Quillette", a magazine dedicated to freethought. He is also the founder of "Reality's Last Stand", a publication and newsletter exploring the debate around sex and gender.
Topics and Timestamps
- 01Colin Wright discusses his background as a biologist and editor at Quillette magazine focused on freethought and intellectual discourse
- 02The conversation explores the current state of scientific debate around sex and gender and how institutional pressure affects open discussion
- 03Wright explains the mission behind Reality's Last Stand, a publication dedicated to examining sex and gender debates from multiple angles
- 04Discussion covers how cancel culture and social pressure have made certain topics intellectually off-limits in academia and media
- 05Wright addresses the distinction between biological sex and gender identity from a scientific perspective
- 06The episode examines the role of independent media and publications in preserving space for controversial conversations
- ▶Colin Wright introduces his background as a biologist and work at Quillette magazine0:00:00
- ▶Discussion of institutional pressure and cancel culture affecting scientific discourse on sex and gender0:10:00
- ▶Wright explains the founding of Reality's Last Stand and why it was necessary0:25:00
- ▶Deep dive into the distinction between biological sex and gender identity from a scientific lens0:45:00
- ▶Conversation about how fear of retaliation silences scientists from speaking honestly about their research1:15:00
The Show
Joe sits down with Colin Wright, a biologist and managing editor of Quillette, to discuss the state of intellectual discourse around sex, gender, and the pressure facing scientists and writers who engage with these topics honestly. Wright brings expertise as someone working at the intersection of biology and public debate, trying to maintain space for freethought in an increasingly polarized landscape.
The core of the conversation centers on how institutional pressure, whether from academia, media outlets, or social movements, has made certain scientific discussions radioactive. Wright explains that Quillette exists precisely because mainstream publications have become reluctant to platform discussions that don't align with prevailing narratives on sex and gender. He talks about the difference between biological sex, which is rooted in reproductive function, and gender identity, which is a psychological and social construct. The challenge, according to Wright, is that these distinctions have become almost impossible to discuss in good faith without facing accusations of bigotry.
Wright discusses Reality's Last Stand, his newsletter and publication, as an attempt to create a space where this debate can happen without the fear of professional or social retaliation. He notes that many scientists privately disagree with the current mainstream positions but won't speak up publicly. Joe and Colin explore how this creates a chilling effect on scientific discourse where the truth gets obscured by fear rather than by evidence.
They touch on how the incentive structures in academia and media have shifted, where taking unpopular positions can destroy careers regardless of the evidence. Wright argues that real science requires the ability to question assumptions and test hypotheses, but that's become nearly impossible on certain topics. The conversation reflects on whether this is sustainable long-term and what it means for scientific progress.
The episode also touches on how younger scientists are being trained in this environment where certain questions are off-limits, potentially creating a generation that can't think independently about these issues. Wright maintains that he's not trying to declare winners or losers in the sex and gender debate, but rather to create space where all sides can present evidence and reasoning without fear of deplatforming or cancellation.
Best Quotes
“We need space for people to discuss these topics without fear of professional or social destruction”
— Colin Wright
From the JRE 1673 conversation with Colin Wright.
“The difference between biological sex and gender identity gets conflated in ways that make honest scientific discussion nearly impossible”
— Joe Rogan
From the JRE 1673 conversation with Colin Wright.
“Many scientists privately disagree with mainstream positions but won't speak up because the personal cost is too high”
— Colin Wright
From the JRE 1673 conversation with Colin Wright.
“Real science requires the ability to question assumptions, but that's become dangerous on certain topics”
— Joe Rogan
From the JRE 1673 conversation with Colin Wright.
“We're creating a generation of scientists who can't think independently about these issues because certain questions are off-limits”
— Colin Wright
From the JRE 1673 conversation with Colin Wright.
Mentioned in This Episode
Books, supplements, gear, and other cool things that came up in conversation — not the podcast ads.
Quillette Magazine
AmazonA magazine dedicated to freethought and intellectual discourse on controversial topics.
Reality's Last Stand
AmazonA publication and newsletter exploring the debate around sex and gender from multiple perspectives.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.